What Is The Most Cost Effective Roof Replacement?

Get Free Estimate

The replacement of a roof is not a cheap or easy endeavor. It may take several days to finish and will likely cost more money than you intended. This is especially the case if you don’t know about the many different types of materials available in the industry. There are ways to get the job done with the cheapest materials possible so you do not exceed your budget. Remember that less expensive materials are typically not as durable and often need to be replaced sooner than more costly options.

Asphalt shingles are generally the most cost-effective material available when it comes to roofing. You could also go with some plastic and corrugated metal panels, which can provide a cheaper-than-average option. However, in most cases, they need to be able to withstand your local climate to justify the cost savings.

What are Asphalt Shingles?

Asphalt shingles are roof shingles made of overlapping sheets. These sheets, covered with granules of an effervescent surface, are composed of a mixed material of asphalt and fiberglass. They overlap and are taped down to give a waterproof effect. So, whenever a rainstorm blows in, the water cannot penetrate through to the interior of the house. Shingles also have great UV resistance and can withstand various weather conditions in all climates.

Asphalt Shingles Installation in Michigan by West Michigan Roof and Gutter

Why are Asphalt Shingles the Most Cost-Effective for Roof Replacement?

Compared to other roofing materials, asphalt shingles are more cost-effective because they are relatively easy to install and keep up. They are lightweight and do not need much support, so the installation process goes quickly, and labor costs are kept low. Their low maintenance also makes life easier for you. So, expect good value for your money from asphalt shingles. They are lower in cost than metal, slate, or ceramic roofing.

The durability of asphalt shingles is widely recognized. They can endure various weather conditions, from extreme heat to heavy precipitation. Luxury asphalt shingles can remain intact for thirty years or longer, effectively ensuring the safety and security of one’s personal property. Their ability to last several years lowers the average cost of their use and, importantly, reduces the need for costly repairs and replacements.

Yet another factor improves the value of asphalt shingles: They require very little upkeep. Asphalt shingles don’t need regular sealing or painting, which other building materials require. Besides requiring low maintenance, asphalt shingles are also easy to repair in terms of effort and expense. If one of them becomes damaged, you can replace that single unit rather than rip out the whole roof.

Not only are asphalt shingles practical and cost-effective, but they can also improve the look of your home. They come in different textures, styles, and colors, allowing you to match the appearance of your property. With asphalt shingles, you may create an attractive and personalized appearance for your home while still maintaining cost-effectiveness.

What are the things to consider when choosing asphalt shingles?

Asphalt Shingles Durability in Michigan

Durability

The resilience of asphalt shingles is a pivotal aspect to consider when choosing the appropriate shingle type for your roof. Different shingle types offer varying degrees of sturdiness, so one has to be aware of the determinants affecting the longevity of their shingles. If you have a three-tab shingle roof, it will last for 15-20 years under mild circumstances. Still, providing adequate protection in areas with major weather conditions such as heavy winds and hail would be highly unlikely. Three tabs are generally designed to withstand wind speeds up to 60-65 miles per hour.

Conversely, architectural shingles are more durable and tougher due to their depth. They can last up to 25-30 years in decent conditions and resist severe wind and hail. Luxury shingles generally have a lifespan of 30 years or more under typical conditions, and their increased mass allows them to withstand above-average wind speeds, sometimes even up to 110 mph.

Appearance

The type of shingle you select can significantly impact the look of your home, and several different options are available. Asphalt shingle types are three-tab shingles, architectural shingles, and luxury shingles, and each type is available in various colors. Three-tab shingles are the most basic and economical option. Still, they have a flat and uniform appearance, typically a single-layer product with a granulated surface, and are available in a limited range of colors.

The architectural shingles still have the staple shingle design but are not the same as three-tab shingles. The architectural shingles consist of two or more layers of asphalt that are laminated together and give the shingle a textured appearance. The architectural shingles still come in hundreds of colors and styles.

Budget

While it can be fun to talk about the different color options, that’s not the topic that most homeowners want to discuss. More often than not, homeowners want to know about the price of these shingles. Roof replacement can be an expensive project, and the price you’ll pay can vary depending on the types of shingles you choose to install.

The average price of 3-tab shingles ranges from $75 to $100 per square and has a 20-to-25-year warranty. They are the cheapest of all the shingle styles. They cost the least and are great for homeowners who need to replace their roofs on a budget. Architectural shingles are typically 20% more expensive than three-tab shingles, costing between $100 and $125. Their cost is higher because they are built to give off the appearance of realistic wood and stone roofing. They also have much more coverage and craftsmanship in the shingles, as well as more variations in color and patterns.

If you want a luxury shingle, expect to pay around $150 to $250 or more per square. The price difference is substantially due to luxury shingles having more features and being made of more materials. Luxury shingles are often composed of many layers to give them a shingle-lined look. They are usually randomly textured, and the colors are often varied and random.

Other Cost-Effective Options

1. Metal Roofing

With metal pieces or tiles able to withstand corrosion, resist water, and maintain durability, a metal roof is a long-lasting roofing option. Whether a foundational, non-waterproof roof needs a protective covering or a freestanding roof, metal can be incorporated into a building’s structure as part of its protective envelope.

2. Solar Roofing Shingles

These solar shingles are designed to replace existing shingles, lay alongside, and blend in with standard roof coverings. Solar shingles are very similar to solar panels. They absorb sunlight and convert it into electricity. In addition to the shingles producing energy, the solar roof shingles are also aesthetically pleasing. Rather than one large, reflective solar panel, solar shingles can be installed, giving your roof a similar look to what you have now. Without breaking the bank, solar shingles can change the way you think about generating electricity.

Solar Roofing Shingles in Michigan by West Michigan Roof and Gutter

3. Tile Roofing

Tiles overlap each other to form a roof that blocks rain and snow. In some areas, tiles are made of clay, and in others, they are made of slate, both of which are available locally. The newer tile roofs are made from concrete and plastic materials.

Tile Roofing Michigan by West Michigan Roof and Gutter

4. Asphalt Roofing

One popular roofing material choice is asphalt shingles. Made from a mix of bitumen and fiberglass, the material is extremely versatile and can easily adapt to any climate. Asphalt shingles are black or gray in their natural state, but various pigments can be added to the material to produce a more vibrant color. The shingles can be reinforced with organic or inorganic materials, which shape and strengthen the shingle.

Factors to Consider When Choosing a Roof Replacement Material

  • Slope of the Roof
  • Authenticity in Architecture
  • Weather endurance
  • Maintenance Over an Extended Time
  • Efficiency of Energy Use
  • Weight of Materials
  • Range in Pricing

It’s an all-or-nothing principle when you decide on cheap roof replacement for your home using affordable roofing components. When you select a more economical material, the roof’s life span will be shorter than its long-lasting counterpart. Investing a little more in a quality material that lasts longer would be worth it. This is why we prefer using asphalt shingles, which is a nice compromise between both price and sustainability.

GET FREE NO PRESSURE CONSULTATION

CONTACT US

Frequently Asked Questions

This depends on the extent of the damage to your existing roof. Signs that you may need a full replacement include curling or missing shingles, leaks, or evidence of animal infestation in your attic. If your roof is nearing the end of its expected lifespan (typically 20-30 years for asphalt shingles), a full roof replacement might be the most cost-effective option in the long run.